MAN UTD: Player of The Year [Archive] - MaXxed Football Forums

Dirtycheat

13-04-2006, 04:44 PM

who do you think has been the best man utd player this season, basing your vote on performances rather than what the media say or their reputation.

edit: i was going to put wes brown, saha and smith but they havent played too many matches this season and i only have 10 options, if you want to vote for them vote for other and specify who is your choice.

Monne

13-04-2006, 04:46 PM

sylvestre

i don't care what they say, the man is a genius!

varun

13-04-2006, 04:50 PM

sylvestre

i don't care what they say, the man is a genius!
monne your clock just ran out of batteries :p

Rooney for me although Ronaldo has been on fire for the last 2 months now

Dirtycheat

13-04-2006, 04:58 PM

sylvestre

i don't care what they say, the man is a genius!

yes i think silvestre is an unsung hero and asissts more than you'd imagine, plus he had a chance to leave united for lyon or marsielle (cant remember) but he stayed to battle for a place with Hienze and Evra.

but

Rooney runs non stop for us, chases every ball and goes for every tackle he can. he is the sort of striker that defends when the team needs him to, battles in midfield and sets up whoever is his strike partner. he get my vote.

opm1s6

13-04-2006, 05:12 PM

sylvestre

i don't care what they say, the man is a genius!
silvestre shouldn't even be on the list. there isn't even a doubt. if giggs had scored a few more goals I'd start to think about it, but this is too automatic for me.

sirmax858

13-04-2006, 05:14 PM

its obvious....

TIM HOWARD;) :D

nah I think Wayne Rooney or SMith jjust cause Smudge is a bad ass, and he may never play again:(

Rooney for me although Ronaldo has been on fire for the last 2 months now
I agree 100%

Cantona7

13-04-2006, 05:37 PM

i picked rooney ...but there were others who have been in my opinon just as equally brilliant this season...

fanutd

13-04-2006, 05:44 PM

its obvious....

TIM HOWARD;) :D

nah I think Wayne Rooney or SMith jjust cause Smudge is a bad ass, and he may never play again:(

I agree 100%

He will come back and he will comeback stronger.

ronaldo07

13-04-2006, 08:21 PM

For me Ronaldo was very good .

Park also played his part .But for player of the year one and only

Wayne Rooney

lawless7

13-04-2006, 08:26 PM

sylvestre is shit. Ok he has played a few decent games at leftback but he still sucks ass. The guy has been doing fuckery for a long time in the manU defense.A genius hahahaahahahahahahahahah
this is so easy Rooney by a million miles.

ashmufc

13-04-2006, 08:51 PM

Its between van Der Sar, and Rooney, but has to Rooney, he has had great form!

opm1s6

13-04-2006, 10:14 PM

Its between van Der Sar, and Rooney, but has to Rooney, he has had great form!

vds lost it on that stupid goal at blackburn? where him and rio got confused and rio headed it back and into the goal....i blame vds. don't remember which game it was. but think it was blackburn.

realGaurab

13-04-2006, 10:34 PM

I voted Gary Neville. He has been very consistent all season long in the right flank. Roonie, rvn, Ronaldo have all played some games in which they looked really non-existant at times but this guy has been there week in week out. Has been a lot threatning going forward this season.

Yusuf

13-04-2006, 10:37 PM

darrenj

13-04-2006, 10:40 PM

rooney.......what a player

bricktop

14-04-2006, 03:04 AM

I actually think its between Roon and Eddie, despite the couple blunders he had this season. just think of how much more confident the team is knowing that they have a first rate keeper back there instead of Roy Can't Catch Carroll. having him between the sticks is such a relief, I am so much more confident in the back line now and how many times has he come through with a big save to raise confidence or save our arses when we needed it.

Roon for obvious reasons, has been brilliant this season. he hasn't scored as many screamers as last season (like that volley against castle for example), but he is still terrorizing defenses and scoring goals. and also, although this gets overlooked, his passing game has been great this season (look at park's goal last week for example), and he is very unselfish.

tough call between those two, but I think Roon nudges out on top.

Kan

14-04-2006, 03:35 AM

Rooney, great player and has been great this season. If he gets his form right in european club football Man Utd shouldn't have a problem getting past the Group stages. Hope he carry's the form into the world cup but plays crappy next season. :p

harithfakhrudin

14-04-2006, 03:46 AM

silvestre shouldn't even be on the list. there isn't even a doubt. if giggs had scored a few more goals I'd start to think about it, but this is too automatic for me.

sylvest is a good player. but if the manager keeps him on and off, it's pretty hard for him to perform well.

but, i think rooney is the best player for man utd this year.

harithfakhrudin

14-04-2006, 03:47 AM

He will come back and he will comeback stronger.

exactly. he'll come back a better player.

ronalba7

14-04-2006, 06:59 AM

rooney!! he has been absolutely superb this season.....:rolleyes:

^_^

14-04-2006, 09:14 AM

vds lost it on that stupid goal at blackburn? where him and rio got confused and rio headed it back and into the goal....i blame vds. don't remember which game it was. but think it was blackburn.
But how many times has Van der Sar saved our asses this season...? Many many times. Can't just blame it on him for just that mistake alone.

For me it's between Rooney and Van der Sar, probably Rooney after seein his performance against Arse.

Oh and Silvestre has been performin very well at left back. That ball to Rooney on Sunday, brilliant.

The Rock

14-04-2006, 10:13 AM

Oh and Silvestre has been performin very well at left back. That ball to Rooney on Sunday, brilliant.

I know how much of a football fan you are. :)

Yusuf

14-04-2006, 10:53 AM

sylvest is a good player. but if the manager keeps him on and off, it's pretty hard for him to perform well.

but, i think rooney is the best player for man utd this year.
Manager kept him out? I remember him left out for silly mistakes he made. I am glad he is left back again, atleast oppositions dont piss on our defence anymore.

dandan

14-04-2006, 12:28 PM

For me it's Ronaldo. He had a very bad beginning, but I don't blame him, cause he had a lot on his mind. he came back really strong and I can't wait for the Wolrd Cup. The guy is going to be on fire!

Sammy 21

14-04-2006, 12:31 PM

I'd say Rooney.

Saha has also made a great comeback too.

bakanbonko

14-04-2006, 01:54 PM

for me Rooney is simply the best that he is :D

FowlOleRon

14-04-2006, 02:18 PM

For me it has to be Rooney.

Some of his touches on the ball are simply sublime

manuforever

14-04-2006, 03:45 PM

ruud is still the better striker imo
yes rooney is in top form, but he finds himself out of position sometimes...
and his finishing is better, and his tally is higher.
and i think park bloomed late. hes an attacking mid, and hadnt scored many, btu is now coming out of his shell..!

sirmax858

14-04-2006, 04:58 PM

He will come back and he will comeback stronger.

trust me i hope soo too, but what really is the chance that he will comeback stronger. An injury like this is a horrid one. It will take some work and i think he'll be back on the pitch, but hes going to think twice on tackles, and what i really like about smudge is his fearless atitude...

opm1s6

14-04-2006, 05:02 PM

sirmax858

14-04-2006, 05:16 PM

yeah and how many assists? please, united would be fighting for third with tottenham if it wasn't for rooney.

dont you mean liverpool, tottenham isnt really fighting for third.....

opm1s6

14-04-2006, 06:12 PM

dont you mean liverpool, tottenham isnt really fighting for third.....
dur da durrrrrr

think about it....minus rooney would be in third, fighting to stay in third.

vanistelrooy

16-04-2006, 11:07 AM

:eek: :eek: so many votes for ronaldo!:eek: He played well for 1 or 2 months!We're talking about the whole year!
I vote for Ruud, He is so strong and he scored so many goals:rolleyes:

jOn0

16-04-2006, 11:17 AM

Rooney without a doubt. Decided countless games and scored important goals.

Ziink

16-04-2006, 01:05 PM

Rooney :)

Dirtycheat

16-04-2006, 06:50 PM

:eek: :eek: so many votes for ronaldo!:eek: He played well for 1 or 2 months!We're talking about the whole year!
I vote for Ruud, He is so strong and he scored so many goals:rolleyes:

he scores goals but his al round performance is terrible, we play better football with saha and he isnt credited for that because he isnt exactly as high profile. but it has to be rooney, just a magnicent tallent, i would praise him the same if he wasnt a man united player.

gunnersfan

16-04-2006, 06:52 PM

wheres the option for none.....?

fanutd

16-04-2006, 06:53 PM

wheres the option for none.....?

in the Arsenal Thread :p

gunnersfan

16-04-2006, 07:00 PM

in the Arsenal Thread :p

touche lol :D :p

reddevils

16-04-2006, 08:56 PM

Has to be Rooney for me

rOOnaldo86

16-04-2006, 09:08 PM

Rooneys the obvious choice but I picked Ryan Giggs. He did the job early in the year in the CL before we went out and imo he was the reason we went on that good run the last couple of months. Without him as playmaker in the middle it would have fallen apart.

Doesnt get the credit he deserves imo.

roygabv

16-04-2006, 10:03 PM

If MOTY is based on workrate, Park Ji Sung all the way .... If MOTY is based on overall quality, duh, Ronney no contest...

benzwong

16-04-2006, 10:20 PM

I would have said Rooney but after giving some thoughts,

Park deserves it. He's running like a mad dog every game. Give him credit for working so hard! :D

Go Park Go!

zyzfr1

16-04-2006, 10:53 PM

There's only one Rooney

http://img232.imageshack.us/img232/926/rooneyge1ip.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

still_undeclared

16-04-2006, 11:37 PM

i'd go with van der sar, he's brought confidence to the backline and been consistent all season long

sporez

18-04-2006, 07:08 AM

evidently saha wasnt an option, went with rooney rather than other. Roon seems less frustrating and more excellent this year than last, and apparently (to me) i see him honing his skills to a fine point with every game, which is really cool to watch! I think of a cooler more consistent Rooney and think yeah maybe United can win the Champions League in next couple of years, and maybe England will win the World Cup. But for this year, Saha gives so much more variety up front, i think in training teams are trying to concentrate on how to play against Ruud, and arent training to play vs Saha's dare I say it - Henry-esqe - style? I don't like arsenal *nervously* heh heh but um wow Les Invincibles were really excellent to watch, and I'm glad it was United that ended their run..so much different than the plod plod tick tock punch in punch out style of Chelski. :rolleyes: