PDA

View Full Version : Mascherano or Diarra - Man Utd

Treadstone
19-04-2006, 06:37 PM
Which of these would you prefer to see at Man Utd and why?

Diarra is very strong and has a nice shot. But Mascherano is young and has a lot of potential i think.

But what do you think?
deviant
19-04-2006, 06:52 PM
Mascherano because he is young and already is very skilled in a couple of years people wont even remember Makalele
dimz
20-04-2006, 04:04 PM
mascherano definitely, i'm still skeptical about players from the French league, even though it's lyon. plus they already said they want more than Essien for Diarra. Mascherano from what i've seen is a much better player anyway.
mambo
20-04-2006, 04:22 PM
Which of these would you prefer to see at Man Utd and why?

Diarra is very strong and has a nice shot. But Mascherano is young and has a lot of potential i think.

But what do you think?

Obviously this question comes in ignorance of the current market-values!
Viera just moved to Juventus for 20mio. €
Why should he move right back ? Mate, he already gets top salaries ;)
varun
20-04-2006, 05:45 PM
macherano end of.

don't trust diara too much
CoachG
20-04-2006, 05:59 PM
too bad heinze is out with injury. mascherano and heinze would work well. i do feel bad for heinze, this was probably his last chance for world cup.
Treadstone
20-04-2006, 07:11 PM
Obviously this question comes in ignorance of the current market-values!
Viera just moved to Juventus for 20mio. €
Why should he move right back ? Mate, he already gets top salaries ;)

Boy oh boy..u guys love to jump off don't you...I said "Diarra" not Viera
mambo
20-04-2006, 07:39 PM
l0l iŽll have another spliff :D
varun
20-04-2006, 09:24 PM
too bad heinze is out with injury. mascherano and heinze would work well. i do feel bad for heinze, this was probably his last chance for world cup.
**sish** are you sleeping or what....heinze is back already mate, he's been in training for 3 weeks, was on the bench against sunderland and might even get a run before the end of the season.....WC is 1+ month away he'll be boogying by then ;)
germinals
22-04-2006, 04:28 AM
BOTH!
why not get both? for me, if man utd really want to challenge for the epl next year they will need at least 2 big signings (ballack is overrated) mascherano would be nice but who do we have that can play beside him and is trustworthy? Diarra would be a nice signing although i wouldnt mind seeing fergie move for Mathieu Bodmer of Lille or even Nolan from Bolton

just hope they don't sell RVN to fund these transfers..shouldn't anyway with the cash from the new sponsor :D